Replace the verdict with a specific observation
“They are not performing” is too broad to investigate. Which outcome is missing? Against which agreed standard? Since when? A missed deadline, repeated error and reluctance to challenge a decision may have different causes.
Begin with examples that both sides can examine. Ask what changed in the task, workload, tools, authority and support. Give the person room to explain their experience. Do not infer a private health condition or a fixed trait from a change in output.
Why looking at context is reasonable
Fit research gives a reason to examine the relationship between a person and their work. Kristof-Brown and colleagues found associations across different kinds of fit and work outcomes; that does not establish why a particular employee is struggling. [1]
Humphrey and colleagues’ work-design meta-analysis links motivational, social and contextual job features to attitudes and behaviours. Its 259 studies support considering working conditions alongside the individual. They do not establish that the environment explains every performance problem. [2]
Psychological safety adds another question: can people ask for help or challenge an assumption? Frazier and colleagues synthesized evidence on psychological safety and work outcomes. Use that as a reason to examine team conditions, not to diagnose a team from a short questionnaire. [8]
Role clarity is worth examining
Tubre and Collins found a negative association of about −.21 between role ambiguity and job performance. Results varied by job type and rating source. This is not a 21% productivity loss, and it does not prove that a clearer brief will improve any particular employee’s output by a fixed amount. [10]
For a team discussion, it gives a specific question: do people agree on the outcome, authority and standard expected? Test the answer with a real task, not only with a general rating of how clear the role feels.
Three questions about the work
Are the decisions clear? Someone accountable for delivery may still need approval for every important choice. Map who decides, when approval is needed and how disagreements are resolved.
Does the workload fit the available capacity? Constant interruptions or too many parallel priorities can make a capable person look inconsistent. Look at the calendar and task queue before interpreting the pattern.
Is the support appropriate to the task? Missing examples, unclear quality standards or limited practice can resemble a lack of ability. Training, coaching or better tools may be useful. There is no evidence-based rule here that two or three “mismatches” establish poor fit.
A fictional example: the promotion changes the work
An excellent analyst becomes a team lead. The new role requires frequent interruptions, delegation and difficult conversations. Their former success does not guarantee immediate success in these different tasks.
That does not prove they are “the wrong type” for leadership. They may need practice, clearer authority, a manageable team size or a realistic transition period. They may also decide that a specialist route suits their goals better. The point is to examine the change before prescribing a solution.
Agree a change and a fair review
Choose one plausible explanation and a proportionate change. For example, reduce parallel priorities, define a quality checklist or provide supervised practice. Agree what improvement would look like and when to review it.
Keep a record of what changed and what happened. If the first explanation does not hold, revise it. A working experiment cannot establish causality like a controlled study, but it can make the next conversation more grounded.
Training is not automatically the wrong answer to a fit problem. Roles and skills can change. Equally, changing someone’s tasks does not resolve every capability or conduct issue. Keep alternative explanations open.
Use HOS to open questions
A HOS conversation may help people articulate different expectations. The report is an evolving interpretation of answers, not a validated diagnostic explanation of underperformance.
Discuss the situation before selecting a questionnaire. Any formal employment decision needs job-related evidence and a fair process; a HOS category should not make that decision. The purpose is a clearer next step, not a label attached to a person.
Studies and sources
The linked studies investigate related concepts. They do not validate the HOS model or its assessments. Some publisher pages offer only an abstract; full text may require payment.
- [1] Kristof-Brown, A. L., Zimmerman, R. D., & Johnson, E. C. (2005). Consequences of individuals’ fit at work: A meta-analysis of person–job, person–organization, person–group, and person–supervisor fit. Personnel Psychology, 58(2), 281–342.DOI: 10.1111/j.1744-6570.2005.00672.x · Additional source
- [2] Humphrey, S. E., Nahrgang, J. D., & Morgeson, F. P. (2007). Integrating motivational, social, and contextual work design features: A meta-analytic summary and theoretical extension of the work design literature. Journal of Applied Psychology, 92(5), 1332–1356.DOI: 10.1037/0021-9010.92.5.1332 · Additional source
- [8] Frazier, M. L., Fainshmidt, S., Klinger, R. L., Pezeshkan, A., & Vracheva, V. (2017). Psychological safety: A meta-analytic review and extension. Personnel Psychology, 70(1), 113–165.DOI: 10.1111/peps.12183 · Additional source
- [10] Tubre, T. C., & Collins, J. M. (2000). Jackson and Schuler (1985) revisited: A meta-analysis of the relationships between role ambiguity, role conflict, and job performance. Journal of Management, 26(1), 155–169.DOI: 10.1177/014920630002600104 · Additional source
